Abolishing formal consultations could be the first step to better citizen engagement

By Rebecca Willis

The government recently announced plans to abolish formal consultation processes. Is this bad news for those of us working to improve public engagement, democratic accountability and climate policy making?

That’s a tricky question.

The problem with consultations

There are hundreds of consultations every month, many on highly technical or obscure topics. Trade associations, environmental organisations, academics and civil society groups do their best to respond but influence often depends less on their knowledge or experience of the issue and more about the size of their public affairs team.

Consultations also tend to ask detailed questions about policy design rather than the bigger questions about whether an approach is right in the first place. Whenever I’ve responded to one, the questions have never fitted; I’m always tempted to say, ‘I wouldn’t start from there’. I was once told that there’s a government office many miles from Whitehall staffed with long-suffering clerks who read and summarise consultation responses. I’m not sure if that’s true, though government itself says it spends £20 million a year on responding to consultations and predictably enough, was already investigating AI-driven alternatives. Meanwhile, the savvier influencers know that what speaks loudest is not any formal process, but informal networks and connections, which again require investment and nurturing.

So, I didn’t shed tears when I saw the announcement to abolish consultations. It signalled the end to a performative charade that privileged well-resourced interest groups.

Why consultations still matter

And yet, formal consultations serve an important democratic purpose. They are a formal check on policymaking, allowing anyone to offer evidence and influence a government policy before it is finalised.

They create a record of evidence presented, and the positions of different groups. A consultation on airport expansion, for example, requires those who support the expansion, and those who oppose it, to set out their case, in the form of economic analysis, technology claims or citizen views. Private lobbying will always play a role, but it feels important, in democratic decision making, for stakeholders to offer up their evidence for scrutiny. My colleague Matthew Lockwood has written about how consultation processes can be used to hold powerful lobbies to account, and what happens when this isn’t possible.

Even if the consultation process favours those with resources and knowhow, the fact that it is an open, formal opportunity to comment on policy formation has symbolic importance. It sends a signal that government can’t just do what it wants but must have processes in place to listen and respond. Voting in elections every few years is a very blunt way of holding government to account. People also need opportunities to shape policies between elections.

And so, removing formal consultations without committing to other participation mechanisms for stakeholder organisations and citizens feels like democratic backsliding.

What comes next?

It all hinges on what will happen instead, and so far, the government has been tantalisingly, and worryingly, silent on this point. Does it agree that it is important to have formal systems which allow citizens and organisations to put evidence on the table? How will it ensure that civil servants developing policy, whether at national or local level, can access the best evidence about the opportunities and impacts of different options?

These questions remain unanswered. But there is an interesting statement about the importance of citizen engagement:

“In many instances, the best approach will be more participatory policymaking. Involving a wider range of people in shaping our thinking earlier and more directly – with ministers and officials leading engagement in ways that reflect the issue at hand, and which help to build back public trust in government.”

This is exactly what we have been arguing for on climate issues, and there is solid research that citizens would welcome such an approach.

Building better participation

Recent years have seen some brilliant efforts to bring wider voices into policymaking and policy advice. Initiatives such as Change NHS, which sought input into the NHS Ten Year Plan and combined structured deliberative events for citizens and NHS staff with an online portal for ideas and views; and PolicyLab efforts to build ethnographic methods into evidence for the Windrush Inquiry. The Climate Change Committee, as independent advisers to government and parliament, use Citizens’ Panels, bringing together a group of randomly selected people who match the profile of the UK population, to offer their views and experience and shape the Committee’s advice. This follows an earlier Citizens’ Assembly, Climate Assembly UK, established by Parliament to bring citizen voices into the conversation about how to reach climate goals. In Jersey, the debate on assisted dying started with a Citizens’ Jury, which recommended proceeding with caution, creating a more inclusive and nuanced debate on the issue than we have managed in the UK parliament.

These approaches offer something that traditional consultations often struggle to achieve: genuine dialogue between citizens and government.

They also provide vital evidence for policymakers, about how to shape policies which fit people’s values and lived experiences. Social intelligence of this sort is just as important as the standard analytical techniques that inform policymaking, such as economic analysis or technological forecasting. Good policymaking depends not only on knowing what is possible, but also on understanding what people need and value.

Although these examples are impressive, they are not the norm. If the formal consultation process is abolished, it must be replaced with something better. Government needs to set clear requirements on consultation and engagement and provide dedicated support for policymakers to choose methods that work for the issue in question.

What climate policy tells us

Our work on climate and energy policy points to the potential for new models of consultation and engagement. As we set out in our new briefing, a large majority in the UK support action on climate change and want to see government taking a lead. At the same time, levels of trust are low. They want reassurances that policies can be shaped by them, and in ways that work for them.

Our research suggests that effective engagement should include:

  • A shared vision. Government should communicate clear and consistent policy priorities and how they link to people’s lives and aspirations. Citizens themselves should play a role in drawing up these priorities, through Citizens’ Assemblies and similar processes, not as one-offs but as permanent features of decision-making. This increases people’s understanding that policymaking is done for them and, in part, by them.
  • Better policy design. Detailed consultation and engagement around specific topics help to ensure policies are designed in ways that work for people. Our Citizens’ Panel on energy demand, for example, shows how to shape policies for food, transport and housing, learning from people’s experience. More detailed engagement can be designed in many ways, not just through formal processes like Citizens’ Assemblies. Participatory budgeting, reaching people through existing community groups, and online tools can all play a role.
  • A focus on who the policy is likely to affect, not just whose voice is loudest. A significant majority of people support ambitious government action on climate, and have views on how policies could be designed, but most people will not make their views known unless asked. Policymaking should seek out the views of those who are affected by decisions, not simply those most likely to speak up.
  • Greater democratic engagement at local levels. Devolution does not necessarily mean democratisation, but as more decision-making powers move to local and regional levels, there is an opportunity to involve communities more directly in shaping policy.
  • A role for organisations and experts. Participation is not just about individual citizens. Trade unions, business groups, academics and civil society organisations provide valuable evidence and insight. They often function as a conduit for people’s views and experience, and so any replacement for consultations must continue to provide formal opportunities for these groups to contribute.
  • Stronger safeguards on lobbying. Anyone should have the opportunity to shape policy, but high standards of transparency and accountability should ensure that loud voices are not enabled by deep pockets.

More participation, not less

Few will mourn the loss of the consultation process. But if formal consultations disappear, they must be replaced by something better.
The goal should not be fewer opportunities for people to engage with government, but more. More dialogue. More transparency. More participation. More accountability.

At its best, democracy is a conversation between governments and the people they serve. If the end of formal consultations helps create better ways of having that conversation, it could strengthen, rather than weaken, our democracy.

The views and opinions expressed in this piece by authors and contributors are their own and do not reflect the official policy, position, or opinions of PACT, our partners or our funders. For more information, please visit our website.